The Biden administration and Congress are concerned about drug prices, they claim. Really? It would be so easy to lower drug prices quickly, simply by opening our borders to drugs from verified pharmacies abroad. Instead, for the first time, the US is negotiating drug prices for ten drugs, and those prices will only be available to Medicare. Noah Weiland and Rebecca Robbins report for The New York Times on a recent Senate HELP Committee hearing.
The Senate HELP Committee held a hearing on drug prices last week. The heads of three pharmaceutical companies had to defend their prices at the hearing. There was lots of talk and little action about why every other wealthy nation pays less for their prescription drugs than we do.
CEOs at Johnson & Johnson, Merck and Bristol Myers Squibb admitted that we pay more for our drugs in the US than people in other wealthy countries. In exchange, they claim that we get new drugs sooner. Clearly some spin doctor advised that they praise this “patient choice” in the US. What was left unsaid is that “choice” is only available to the wealthy. Countless Americans cannot afford their drugs even with health insurance because the copays are so high.
Senator Bernie Sanders, for reasons that I have never understood, is constantly comparing drug prices in the US with those in Canada and sometimes arguing that Americans should be able to import drugs from Canada. Canada has the second highest drug prices in the world. Why not France and England, which have far lower prices?
Sanders was looking for the CEOs to voluntarily agree to lowering their prices to the same level as Canada. How could they possibly agree to reduce their revenue and profits voluntarily? In fact, they have filed lawsuits against the federal government (which they are so far losing), claiming that negotiated prices for ten drugs through the Inflation Reduction Act is unconstitutional!
Republicans on the HELP Committee appear to believe that the pharmaceutical market is working. In fact, Congress affords pharmaceutical companies lengthy patent rights and ways to extend them. The pharmaceutical market is fixed to give pharmaceutical companies monopoly pricing power for lengthy periods.
Senator Romney would like you to believe that the pharmaceutical market works like the automobile market. Not at all. With cars, there’s competition based on lots of known information, including the costs and benefits of the automobile. With drugs, people often don’t know their value. Moreover, the price is rigged by the manufacturers, the pharmacy benefit managers and the health insurers.
We are paying about three times more than people in other countries for our drugs. Shame on Congress.
Here’s more from Just Care:
- Drug prices continue to be around three times higher in the US than other wealthy nations
- FDA allows Florida to import lower-cost drugs from Canada
- Six tips for keeping your drug costs down if you have Medicare
- Importing drugs from abroad should be legal
- Case study: Costco saves one couple hundreds of dollars over Medicare Part D