Health and financial security What's Buzzing

Another study confirms, it’s the prices, stupid

Written by Diane Archer

Why do we spend so much more on health care than other countries? In 2003, Gerard Anderson and Uwe Reinhard et al. explained, It’s the prices stupid: Why the US is so different from other countries. But, some very intelligent people believe otherwise. A new international study on health care spending, by Irene Papanicolas, PhD, Liana Woskie, MSc and Ashish Jha, MD, MPH, confirms, it’s the prices, stupid.

These researchers looked at health care services in other countries to better understand why the US spends about twice as much per capita as other countries. In a Vox interview, Jha explained that he was surprised by their findings. Contrary to what he had been telling people, excessive use of specialty care has not been responsible for high health care spending in the US. Indeed, the US has about the same mix of primary care and specialty care as other wealthy countries. And, health care in the US looks a lot like health care in other countries.

Americans visit the doctor about as frequently as people in other comparable countries. Indeed, we go to the doctor and use the hospital slightly less on average than other wealthy countries. We do get more CAT scans and knee replacements than people in every other country. And, we get more MRIs than people in other countries, with the exception of Germany. But, we get significantly fewer hip replacements than the Swiss, the Germans, the Danes, the French and the Swedes.

Rather than quantity of services, the data show that the big difference between the US and other countries is that we spend more on drugs, devices, labor and services. Jha also thinks Americans use too many services. But, so do people in peer countries. To look more like those countries, we need to address the prices we pay for our services and our administrative costs. Focusing on utilization will not rein in spending sufficiently.

Here’s more from Just Care:



  • It’s not just the prices. I recently had a doctor prescribe two treatments that required expensive equipment and someone to help me use them (i.e. a caretaker). The doctor didn’t even bother to ask me if I had someone to help me or if I lived alone or with one of my children. I paid for the first equipment that I could little afford. Medicare paid for the second equipment. Neither treatment helped so Medicare and I were both charged for useless equipment and I can’t send it back. Doctors need to realize that times have changed and should not assume that the patient has unlimited help and/or funds.

  • I’ve been reading about Bruce Lipton’s discovery. He’s a microbiologist and discovered the reason people get sick, and it has nothing to do with genes. It isn’t what I thought. I think it will replace medicine completely in the future b/c we won’t be able to afford it anymore. And I hope it does.

Leave a Comment

Read previous post:
This is your brain on exercise

To support brain health, we know many things that people should not do, such as smoke, drink alcohol heavily, use...