Health and financial security • What's Buzzing

Private health insurance is broken: Insurers’ market power drives up costs

Written by Diane Archer

Are you wondering why private insurance prices are so high? One of many reasons is the that the big insurers have tremendous market concentration and power. A new report from the American Medical Association (AMA) finds that in almost half of all metropolitan areas in the US, one health insurer controls half or more of the commercial market, reports Mark Rosanes for Insurance Business. With that kind of power, insurers have a lot of leeway to set premiums and out-of-pocket costs as they please.

Many states have commercial health insurance markets that are highly concentrated. They are not really competitive. States that have highly concentrated health insurance markets include Alabama, Kentucky, Hawaii, Louisiana, Michigan, Illinois, Alaska, Indiana, Vermont, and West Virginia. Employers cannot shop around in these states in a meaningful way for lower cost insurance.

Almost all metropolitan commercial health insurance markets are highly concentrated. In those markets, one or more insurers control at least 30 percent of the market. In nearly half of the markets–47 percent–one insurer controls 50 percent of the market. If you ask me, there’s little or nothing the states or federal government can do about this health insurer market concentration any time soon. That said, they have never tried to address this issue in meaningful ways, even though this market concentration has existed for a long time.

The federal government could inject a public health insurance option–an improved traditional Medicare with an out-of-pocket limit and additional benefits–into the market. It could compete with the private health insurers as a way to drive down costs for everyone.

Insurers offering Medicare Advantage plans also control a lot of the insurance markets. Nearly all metropolitan markets have a high Medicare Advantage insurer market concentration. UnitedHealth controls about 30 percent of the markets, Humana controls about 17 percent and CVS controls about 12 percent.

Here’s more from Just Care:

FacebookTwitterPrintFriendly