Health and financial security What's Buzzing

US health care system ranks last in meeting patient’s health care needs

Written by Diane Archer

A report, published in Health Affairs, analyzes 2016 survey data on patients’ experiences with the health care system in 11 countries. It finds that the US health care system ranks last–at the bottom of the barrel–in meeting the needs of patients, when compared with health care systems in other wealthy countries. All of the other countries have universal health care.

Of the people surveyed across 11 countries, people in the US are less healthy and more likely to face material hardship, because of the health care system. US health care is less affordable and does a worse job of getting people quick access to medical care, except specialty care.

People in the United States struggle more than others to access care. One in three adults in the US, a higher percentage than in any other country, reported difficulty accessing care because of the cost. Every other country does a better job protecting residents from the costs of health care.

The UK does the best job of ensuring health care is affordable for everyone. Germans were the least likely to face financial barriers to care. The Netherlands had the best health system based on overall survey results.

No country did a great job of engaging patients or managing chronic care, particularly patients with low incomes. But, the US led the pack on social challenges that affected health. More than people in other countries, Americans reported being “always” or “usually” concerned about having money to buy meals and pay for their housing. Germans were least concerned.

In other countries, people were more likely to have difficulty affording dental care. But, affordability of dental care presented the greatest issues for Americans. People in the Netherlands, the UK and Germany had the least problem accessing dental care.

On the issue of quick access to care, again the US ranked below other countries. In the Netherlands and New Zealand, eight in ten people said they could see a doctor within a day or two. Only in the Netherlands could most people (75 percent) get health care at night and on the weekends without having to go to the emergency room.

Canadians struggled most to get primary care. Three in ten Canadians needed to wait at least two months. Nearly as many adults in Norway also waited at least two months for primary care. In France, Germany, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the United States, only about one in ten adults waited that long.

Of note, the US performed best in one category–doctors engaging patients in discussions about exercise and good nutrition–staying healthy. The report authors suggest that the US could further improve. And, they suggested that it may be that the US performs better because relative to the other 10 countries in the study we have higher rates of obesity and lead less active lives.

People surveyed lived in Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the US.

To improve health outcomes in the US, we need Medicare for All. Please sign this petition.

Here’s more from Just Care:


Leave a Comment

Read previous post:
People with serious health needs more likely to disenroll from Medicare Advantage plans

A new study by David Meyers, Brown University School of Public Health, et al., of people enrolled in Medicare Advantage...